Ostrich Leadership

August 26th, 2010

I never cease to be amazed by how many skilled leaders remain silent at critical moments when even the casual observer can see that the situation calls for the leader to speak out. I call this the “ostrich” dilemma paying homage to the pervasive (though false) notion that, in response to danger, these flightless avians bury their heads in the sand. Leaders come to believe that if they do not respond in the midst of a leadership moment then they will somehow be less responsible for what unfolds in response to their silence. I have no idea what was in the minds of Feisal Abdul Rauf or President Obama as they seemingly hesitated to respond to the mosque situation; I’m not sure any distant observer really does. But I do know from my work with hundreds of leaders that while leadership silence is sometimes a strategic move to help empower constituents to act with autonomy, it is far too often the product of indecision, anxiety, and fear.

This is not rocket science. As human beings, crisis and danger can lead to fight or flight responses. Freezing up and not knowing what to do is a manifestation of flight. But part of a skilled leader’s toolkit is the ability to override that response because their constituents, their organizations, and their societies need them to. People need the model of an alternative to paralysis. And most leaders, being that they are humans, have to work to develop that skill. The problem is that too many do not. Or if they have the skill they misapply it.

Let me pause before this ends up sounding too much like an ivory-tower-egghead critique by someone who has never been under fire. Actually, that would be kind of accurate. My leadership experiences don’t compare in scope to those of a head of state or of a leader of a religious or social movement. But even in my experiences of crises in my professional and civic leadership, I have behaved like a proverbial ostrich on more than one occasion. I have found myself stymied by the complexity and anxiety of pressure leadership moments. I didn’t know what to do. I worried that any move, one way or the other, would have negative consequences for the situation and for the people who were counting on me. And I really didn’t want to look bad in front of my constituents because I made the wrong choice; I didn’t want to look incompetent.

I’ve learned from many powerful leaders and from my own experience that leadership is knowing that there is never a fence to sit on. Leaders I’ve worked with strategically employ a “wait and see” tactic in response to a range of demands on them from crises to simple requests, but they often fail to realize that just because they have chosen silence, that doesn’t mean the situation pauses. Followers don’t tolerate leadership vacuums. If a leader is silent, his or her followers make up stories about why that leader is not responding, stories full of drama and intrigue that often blame the leader and fail to help the situation. Leaders have to be cognizant of this and mindful to obliterate ambiguity with voice and action, especially in the midst of crisis and fear.

Leaders never have time off. Even when a leader takes a vacation, his or her persona as a leader remains present in the minds and hearts of followers. Just ask Tony Hayward.

2 Responses to “Ostrich Leadership”

  1. This seems to be a pattern for Obama. He had the same delayed response, and rather lame at that, with the recent BP oil spill crisis. He was criticized then.

    When it comes to corporate or civic leaders, in the event of a crisis, we need to hear something immediately. It doesn’t have to be a perfect speech. Even something as simple as, “I’m looking into this (fill in the blank) and will make a more formal statement soon. But I do care about this issue/crisis and will be taking action.”

    I agree that sometimes our leaders are waiting to say something perfectly at the risk of getting hammered by the ever-scrutinizing media and public. But guess what? They’re going to get hammered anyway. Just let it not be for waiting too long to say something.

  2. Jacqueline Grace says:

    In the meantime, was reading your blog. My how I miss you and Darden. 🙂 Had to quickly comment on your post, “Ostrich Leadership”. Not to open up old wounds, but I could not help but think of the ugly Bahrain incident (and everything that followed after) when I read your post. I’m sure that’s no surprise to you. While I have moved on from the school and I’m SO over that particular situation, this post made me think,”is there still a learning opportunity from the way that situation was handled?” This post, in my opinion, spoke directly to my issue in how that entire incident was handled–from the top all the way down…

Leave a Reply